Draft FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Proposal

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Draft FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Proposal

    Draft FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Proposal

    15 May 2014

    The draft proposal can be downloaded at:

    https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...osal Final.pdf

    Introduction - In the past few years, the rapid development of information and communication technology has resulted in a limited number of well-identified instances of computer assisted cheating, and also in an increased perception by the general public of the vulnerability of chess.
    FIDE and the Association of Chess Professionals jointly identified this as a major cause of concern for the credibility of chess. To put it in simple terms, no one wants to be associated with a sport whose results can easily be affected by computer-assisted cheating. Accordingly in mid-2013 FIDE and the ACP set up the joint “FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Committee”.

    While the Committee was also asked to look at more traditional areas of malfeasance (such as rating fraud, fictitious tournaments and result manipulation), it was soon agreed to focus on fighting computer-assisted play as the most important perceived threat to the integrity of chess. Of course, the Committee retains jurisdiction on the above-mentioned areas as well, but it will deal with them at a second stage of its development, since the current Rules of Chess are deemed to be sufficient to fight these frauds. Computer-assisted cheating has priority both in its threat, and in needed additions to the Laws of Chess and competition policies. Both FIDE and the ACP recognize the importance and urgency of this work.

    This document contains the first set of recommendations from the Committee. The first and most important recommendation is that FIDE establish a permanent Anti-Cheating Commission (ACC). The Commission shall operate with a view to prevent instances of cheating and to avoid the spreading of the related plague of false accusations. In order to achieve this result, it shall:

    1. monitor and constantly improve the anti-cheating system and regulations;
    2. perform sample checks on players and tournaments both on-site and remotely;
    3. receive complaints;
    4. investigate and decide on open cases;
    5. make recommendations to other FIDE Commissions and propose changes to the Laws of Chess, Tournament Regulations, Rating Regulations and Title Regulations.

    The Committee also recommends new procedures for the reporting and investigation of suspected cheating incidents. These recommendations have been developed by involving other FIDE Commissions where needed, such as WCOC, Rules and Tournament Regulations, Qualifications, Ethics, Events and Arbiters. In some cases action has already been taken by these Commissions in the area of anti-cheating, and these changes have been noted in this report.
    _______________

    (Extract)

    Prevention
    The FIDE Laws of Chess that are expected to enter into force on 1 July 2014 introduce new provisions explicitly forbidding the use of external information during a game. Specifically:

    11.3.a During play the players are forbidden to use any notes, sources of information or advice, or analyze any game on another chessboard.

    The Laws also explicitly forbid electronic devices:

    11.3.b During play, a player is forbidden to have a mobile phone and/or other or other device capable of processing or transmitting chess analysis in the playing venue. If it is evident that a player brought such a device into the playing venue, he shall lose the game. The opponent shall win.

    The rules of a competition may specify a different, less severe, penalty.

    They also empower the arbiter to ensure that the above rule is adhered to:

    The arbiter may require the player to allow his clothes, bags or other items to be inspected, in private. The arbiter or a person authorized by the arbiter shall inspect the player and shall be of the same gender as the player. If a player refuses to cooperate with these obligations, the arbiter shall take measures in accordance with Article 12.9.

    Tournament organizers are also free to introduce their own regulations and conditions for events, provided they are in accord with the Laws of Chess.

    In the light of the above premises, the Committee feels that 3 levels of protection are desirable:

    Maximum protection

    - Organizers clearly and carefully designate areas for players (the “Playing Area”) and for spectators. Organizers and arbiters shall prevent getting any chess information from outside the “Playing Area”. Organizers shall try, in so much as possible and reasonable, to avoid contact between players and spectators. If possible provide separate refreshment/toilet/smoking areas for players and spectators.
    - Arbiters should remind players of the existence of the new AC regulations.
    - Tournaments that are found not to materially comply with AC requirements shall not be rated.
    - Organizers and arbiters are encouraged to carry out regular screening tests via the FIDE Internet-based Game Screening Tool
    - Integral application of Law 11.3.b. In case of breach, the arbiter shall take measure in accordance with article 12.9.f and forfeit the player.
    - Additional security in the form of ACC-certified metal detectors/x-ray machines, scanners, electronic jamming devices, manned by qualified security staff, subject to applicable restrictions in each individual jurisdiction. Each tournament should adopt at least one measures from the ones listed in Annex D. The list is to be adjourned on a time-to-time basis by the ACC.
    - Obligation to send in all tournament games in pgn format for screening (only recommended for Rapid and Blitz events).
    - Tournament Director and all arbiters need to be “Anti-Cheating Educated”.
    - Obligation to present the AC Form at least 4 weeks before the start of the tournament (or as otherwise specified in Paragraph 02 of then current FIDE Rating regulations).

    (to be continued)

  • #2
    Re: Draft FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Proposal

    Increased protection

    - Organizers clearly and carefully designate areas for players (the “Playing Area”) and for spectators. Organizers and arbiters shall prevent getting any chess information from outside the “Playing Area”. Organizers shall try, in so much as possible and reasonable, to avoid contact between players and spectators. If possible provide separate refreshment/toilet/smoking areas for players and spectators.
    - Organizers are strongly encouraged to provide for secure storage facilities for electronic devices.
    - Arbiters should remind players of the existence of the new AC regulations.
    - Tournaments that are found not to materially comply with AC requirements shall not be rated.
    - Organizers and arbiters are encouraged to carry out regular screening tests via the FIDE Internet-based Game Screening Tool
    - Additional security in the form of metal detectors/x-ray machines, scanners, electronic jamming devices, manned by qualified security staff, subject to applicable restrictions in each individual jurisdiction. Each tournament should adopt at least one measure from the ones listed in Annex D. The list is to be adjourned on a time to time basis by the ACC.
    - Obligation to send in norm-related tournament games in pgn format for screening.
    - Recommendation to send all games in pgn for screening
    - Tournament Director and 50% of all arbiters need to be “Anti-Cheating Educated”
    - Obligation to present the AC Form at least 4 weeks before the start of the tournament (or as otherwise specified in Paragraph 02 of then current FIDE Rating regulations);
    - Law 11.3.b will be adopted in a milder version to take account of the circumstance that many amateur players will take part in a tournament after work or other social activities. It may become inconvenient or impossible for them to leave all devices out of the playing venue. The ACC therefore recommends to adopt the following rule:

    “In tournaments open to amateur players, the prohibition to introduce electronic devices in the playing venue may, and indeed should be waived. However, under no circumstances a player shall be allowed to carry an electronic device, whether switched on or off, working or not, on his body during play. This includes, but is not limited to, carrying a device in a bag or in the pocket of a jacket. Any player found carrying such a device shall immediately be forfeited his game, with rating points calculated. A second offense during the same tournament shall imply an immediate ban from the tournament, with the player’s name forwarded to the ACC for further investigation.

    Standard protection

    - Arbiters should remind players of the existence of the new AC regulations.
    - Organizers clearly and carefully designate areas for players (the “Playing Area”) and for spectators. Organizers and arbiters shall prevent getting any chess information from outside the “Playing Area”. Organizers shall try, in so much as possible and reasonable, to avoid contact between players and spectators. If possible provide separate refreshment/toilet/smoking areas for players and spectators.
    - Recommendation to use security equipment (1 item)
    - Recommendation to send all available games in pgn for screening
    - Tournament Director needs to be “Anti-Cheating Educated”
    - Law 11.3.b will be adopted in a milder version to take account of the circumstance that many amateur players will take part in a tournament after work or other social activities. It may become inconvenient or impossible for them to leave all devices out of the playing venue. The ACC therefore recommends to adopt the following rule:

    “In tournaments open to amateur players, the prohibition to introduce electronic devices in the playing venue may, and indeed should be waived. However, under no circumstances a player shall be allowed to carry an electronic device, whether switched on or off, working or not, on his body during play. This includes, but is not limited to, carrying a device in a bag or in the pocket of a jacket. Any player found carrying such a device shall immediately be forfeited his game, with rating points calculated. A second offense during the same tournament shall imply an immediate ban from the tournament, with the player’s name forwarded to the ACC for further investigation.

    Organizers of A and B-type events may liaise with the ACC with a view to finding adequate AC measures that are tailored to the tournament’s size and budget.

    The ACC’s decision following contact by the organizers is final.

    The FIDE Internet-Based Game Screening Tool

    FIDE will supply organizers and arbiters with an Internet-based Game Screening Tool that will be accessible to all authorized FIDE officials (IO, IA, ACC members) and National Federations. The Internet-based Game Screening Tool shall be hosted on a FIDE-dedicated webpage and will enable authorized parties to upload games in pgn format for a “fast test” that will identify potential outliers in the tournament – i.e. players whose performance is far above their expected level and potentially compatible with computer-assisted play.

    The results of the “fast test” are to be kept confidential and are only meant to assist the Chief Arbiter in identifying cases that may call for further measures to assure that players are adhering to the rules. If requested, the ACC shall provide assistance to the Chief Arbiter in determining such measures. It should be reminded that only a “full test” can confer reliable statistical evidence on whether the outlier is receiving external help, so that the results of the “fast test” are not applicable for judgments of complaints.

    The Internet-based Game Screening Tool will require the following investment from FIDE:

    i) a multi-processor computer capable of processing a very high number of games per hour;
    ii) adequate storage capacity;
    iii) a dedicated user-friendly Internet-based Graphical User Interface;
    iv) a specific certified software for processing games approved by the ACC;
    v) instructions for use (administrators and end users);
    vi) one or more system administrators;
    vii) a password system for limiting external access;
    viii) a contract with a provider of server facilities;
    ix) ordinary and extraordinary software maintenance at all times.

    Such hardware will also suffice to run full tests monitored by the ACC

    Comment


    • #3
      proposal for the General Assembly

      The 24 page Proposal from the FIDE/ACP Anti-Cheating Committee can be found over here.

      Proposal for the FIDE Assembly (pdf file)

      (Wayne's link above no longer works.)
      Last edited by Nigel Hanrahan; Wednesday, 30th July, 2014, 01:24 PM. Reason: broken link
      Dogs will bark, but the caravan of chess moves on.

      Comment

      Working...
      X