Old randomizing chess opening moves idea ('Theme' Tournaments)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Kevin Pacey
    • 2008-09-15
    • 1928

    #1

    Old randomizing chess opening moves idea ('Theme' Tournaments)

    Old randomizing chess opening moves idea ("Theme" Tournaments)

    Today, 6:24pm
    One Google AI answer to query 'has anyone suggested as a chess variant drawing lots for which opening variation from the standard western chess setup position that a given game must start from like in checkers with such randomly chosen starting moves'?:

    has anyone suggested as a chess variant drawing lots for which opening variation from the standard western chess setup position that a given game must start from like in checkers with such randomly chosen starting moves - Google Search

    "AI Overview

    Yes, this exact concept exists and is known as Theme Chess (or Mandatory Opening Chess).
    While it is much less common today than Chess960 (Fischer Random Chess), which randomizes the pieces on the back rank, the practice of drawing lots to force players into a specific opening from the standard setup has a rich history in both casual play and master-level tournaments. [1]

    The Historic Practice: "Theme" Tournaments

    In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, chess masters faced a similar issue to what checkers players faced: heavily deeply analyzed opening lines leading to predictable draws. To combat this, organizers created Theme Tournaments.
    • How it worked: Before a tournament or a specific round, a specific opening or a set of initial moves (such as the King's Gambit or the Vienna Game) was chosen—often by drawing lots or by organizational decree.
    • The Purpose: Both players were forced to start the game from that specific position rather than the standard starting array, testing their middlegame and endgame skill in sharp, unfamiliar, or unfashionable lines.

    Modern Implementations: "From Position" Play

    The digital age has turned this exact idea into a regular feature rather than a niche variant, though it is usually referred to as a format rather than an entirely separate game:
    • Lichess & Chess.com "From Position" Tournaments: Online chess platforms frequently host tournaments where the starting position is not the standard array, but a randomly or sequentially chosen opening line (e.g., starting exactly after 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bb5 a6).
    • Thematic Correspondence Chess: Correspondence and email chess organizations have long run "Thematic" tournaments where players draw lots or are assigned specific, deep opening variations to explore how computers or human analysis handle them from that specific point forward.
    • Physical Cards: Commercial products, like various educational chess card decks, have been published over the years featuring standard opening variations. Players can shuffle the deck and draw a card to dictate the mandatory opening moves for their game. [1]

    Why it Didn't Become as Famous as Checkers' 3-Move Restriction

    In checkers, the 3-Move Restriction (drawing a card to determine the first three moves for both sides) became the definitive tournament standard because checkers has a much higher natural draw rate and fewer legal opening branches than chess.

    In chess, when Bobby Fischer wanted to eliminate opening memorization, he felt that forcing players into standard openings still rewarded players who simply memorized more variations. He instead chose to scramble the pieces entirely via Chess960, which creates 960 entirely new "books" of opening theory and successfully killed off standard memorization. [1, 2, 3]..."
    Anything that can go wrong will go wrong.
    Murphy's law, by Edward A. Murphy Jr., USAF, Aerospace Engineer
  • Tom O'Donnell
    • 2008-05-31
    • 1438

    #2
    I vaguely recall that at the end of the Kasparov v Short match they played a few exhibition games from pre-selected positions. I think Kasparov was rather unhappy that one of them where he (Kasparov) was Black the starting position was already quite a bit better for White and Kasparov lost. I like the idea of such an event but if you pick a position that is better for White it is a rather large advantage to have an extra White. Also, would you prefer the players get some days to prepare or just find out at the event?
    "Tom is a well known racist, and like most of them he won't admit it, possibly even to himself." - Ed Seedhouse, October 4, 2020.

    Comment

    • Kevin Pacey
      • 2008-09-15
      • 1928

      #3
      Originally posted by Tom O'Donnell View Post
      I vaguely recall that at the end of the Kasparov v Short match they played a few exhibition games from pre-selected positions. I think Kasparov was rather unhappy that one of them where he (Kasparov) was Black the starting position was already quite a bit better for White and Kasparov lost. I like the idea of such an event but if you pick a position that is better for White it is a rather large advantage to have an extra White. Also, would you prefer the players get some days to prepare or just find out at the event?
      Well Tom, I only happened to be putting this sort of idea out on chesstalk as food for thought. Earlier today I was thinking of posting any sort of comment on LinkedIn, and then I recalled that long ago as a young man I 'independently' suggested this sort of 'chess variant idea' to an older fellow than me, and he quickly felt he'd 'refuted' that idea by saying Fischer Random (one of a couple of names for that, by now), or perhaps even something similar to that, under another name, was already a known idea, and that sort of thing would be a clearly better idea (than the old 'theme' tournament idea, that apparently he and I were both unaware of at the time), for the same reason (or at least one of them, perhaps) that Fischer championed his own chess variant for some decades ago by now.



      The Google AI's response that I've quoted (to address your questions to me) does mention that correspondence play has used such a "Theme" tournament drawing of lots for start position, meaning that neither player is surprised anywhere near too close to the time the game must be started by, I'd think. Here in Ottawa (while RA was a place that was welcoming in terms of affordability for an RA chess club, until recently), the RA club, in some years, used to hold both a Fischer Random event one night per season, and a 'Theme' tournament event, also one night per season, a 'Theme' event where everyone knew the opening they had to play (4 rounds Active TC per night, with each player to play White's and Black's side of the pre-selected starting opening position vs. one opponent, with 2 opponents in total to face on that sort of night as I seem to recall).

      The start position would be chosen well in advance (e.g. month[s] before the night in question, by one or more of the RA's club Executive members, I vaguely recall), and it would be announced some night earlier than that (plus, ideally it would be given in the RA chess club's season's schedule's printed/online handout material to club members what the sequence of moves would constitute the start position for the 'theme' event that season, so as to increase the chance that no club member was unaware of what the start position for the 'Theme' tournament would be). That sort of format seems a way of neutralizing any significant edge that White may actually have from the start position that's selected (but even though such games are not to be rated, some players might still feel unhappy a bit anyway, if they themselves somehow thought that any unusually larger White initial edge (than from the standard setup), that at least they perceive it to be, might reduce their 'fairer chance' of winning (or not losing) all of their own games when playing as Black.

      I do recall sometimes players at the RA seemed not to come if a 'Theme' event did not use a start position that they'd normally ever hope to get to from their own chess opening repertoire (especially if it was a narrow one).


      I'll now note as a lengthy aside here that I myself didn't happen to ever go to the club when it was a night in any season to play a (fast TC) Fischer Random event (I did play that online on a website many times though, starting around 2015 perhaps, at chessvariants dot com [a site with free membership, and that has an automated way to choose a random start position for a given chess variant, if deemed desirable by the inventor and/or programmer of such a game that's to be played by email, with diagrams shown on that website at each move]). However, I once overheard a story at the RA bar & grill that on one particular night, before at least one round that night, one or more players 'lobbied' the tournament director to 'roll the dice again'' and thus try to find a start position for that particular round which would be more to their liking. I've since[?] seen somewhere online that 'computer studies' have suggested that some Fischer Random 'start positions' are deemed pretty much level 0.00, while other positions selected at random favour White more than in the start position for classical chess itself.


      Going back to "Theme" Tournaments, perhaps the odds of starting from a position where White is significantly better than 'usual/average' (i.e. from standard start position of classical chess) might be made not as great as they might be in the case of selecting a start position for a Fischer Random event/round. That would be if some 'reputable opening book' and/or chess theory 'database' (that includes modern engine evaluation numbers, e.g. 0.04 of a pawn ahead for White) were to be used to help select the 'Theme' tournament start position, hopefully without it being too unfavourable to a person's own memorized book knowledge (if any) or their style, compared to that of their fellow human opponent. That might also hold even as a consideration for a player who habitually loves to 'book up' (or not) well in advance - perhaps a bit like shades of 'Botvinnik [rematch] rule' when it came to his regaining his title as world chess champion, with deep preparation on how to beat a player he lost to in a match [e.g. Tal] more than once [i.e. due to quickie re-match a year later]. In other words, my guess is as good as yours about what exactly to propose these days for a hypothetical[?] fair/interesting 'Theme' event at world elite chess player level (though I'm okay with RA club's approach to that at 'fairly strong player's at local club level', otherwise).
      Last edited by Kevin Pacey; Thursday, 5 November, 2026, 10:13 PM. Reason: Grammar
      Anything that can go wrong will go wrong.
      Murphy's law, by Edward A. Murphy Jr., USAF, Aerospace Engineer

      Comment

      Working...