Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

[David Peng]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

I would like to see people who haven't played for a century taken off the top player's list

[Precy Mckoy]

Re: Good job Vincent

I think www.uschess.org is an excellent federation website, and we should try to use that as a model.

I remember this from the Japanese, First and foremost they imitated, after that, they innovated, to make it better if not the best!

[Vincent Chow]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

The upcoming events/tournaments has been fixed. I don't know if it is useful or misleading, but I also included a hit counter for amusement.

[Bob Armstrong]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

Hi Vincent:

A nice further improvement - Thanks.

Bob

[Bindi Cheng]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

I would like to see people who haven't played for a century taken off the top player's list

I would like to see people who haven't played since the turn of the millennium to be taken off the top player's list, more fair that way :D

[Bob Armstrong]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

On some lists, the limit is 2 or three years of inactivity, and off the list - activity can either be in Canada, or internationally. But the practical problem is someone has to track the players' activity. I don't know if a program can be written, tied to the CFC rating system , and the FIDE rating system, that would immediately be able to identity those on the list inactive for say 3 years.

I have a list of the top 5 Canadian FIDE rated players, and top 5 FIDE rated Canadian Women players active in the last 2 years, that I publish in the Scarborough CC newsletter, the Scarborough Community of Toronto Chess News & Views. But the issue is that I do have to keep checking to see that the players listed have played. But I have to do it only for 10 players.

It would certainly highlight who the active top players are if we had an up-to-date list like this.

It must be possible - look at the " live " rating list of top players that now exists. It is totally current. Hopefully, since the " Active top 50 " list is relatively few names, there would be some way of doing it.

Bob

P.S. I've drawn to the attention of the CFC a couple of times, that our most active GM, Bator Sambuev ( of the Russian Federation ), but now a landed Canadian, is not on the list. Would be good to correct this. Kovalyov made it and he's with the Argentinian Federation still.

[Gary Ruben]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

It would certainly highlight who the active top players are if we had an up-to-date list like this.

I don't think activity is a criteria for inclusion in the list list. I haven't played in a CFC rated event in well over 30 years and am in the rating list.

Probably a membership requirement wouldn't work. The titled players who would be in the top 10 lists are all likely honourary life members.

Probably not having a pulse wouldn't work as a criteria. If a guy doesn't have to pay a membership and he hasn't played for almost half a century, how would they know if he has a pulse?

[Bob Armstrong]

A Current Top 50 Canadians List

Hi Gary:

They are not talking about wanting the full player master list " current ". They want the " top 50 Canadians " list to be current, so we know how the top players are comparing against each other in active play ( unless your in the top 50 and I missed your name !! :)).

Bob

[Gary Ruben]

Re: A Current Top 50 Canadians List

Hi Bob,

It's hard to exclude players from the top lists when some who haven't been active in Canada are still eligible for the national team. The criteria is a combination of CFC and FIDE rated events but there is no requirement that a player ever participate in another CFC event once he has attained a rating which suits him. It appears he may then use his CFC rating as a constant and his FIDE rating as a variable. If someone has a bad event there is no reason s/he should lose rating points from both rating requirement criteria.

I like the way they call part of the organization a legacy business. It's like a group of lawyers chatting about an estate. :)

Gary

[Egidijus Zeromskis]

Re: A Current Top 50 Canadians List

It's hard to exclude players from the top lists when some who haven't been active in Canada are still eligible for the national team.

Use appropriate names for the list and there will be no confusion.
e.g.:
All time best CFC ratings;
Top CFC ratings list (by definition only the last N years are taken into account);
CFC rating list (everybody is included)

Just wondering: When has V.Anand played in India?

[Gary Ruben]

Re: A Current Top 50 Canadians List

Just wondering: When has V.Anand played in India?

No idea. I don't recall him playing in the last Olympiad either.

Still, as long as qualifications for our team are a blend of CFC and FIDE, it seems publishing the CFC ratings and the top players is transparent.

Possibly it's time to revisit and revise the articles in the CFC Handbook - if that's what's wanted.

[David Peng]

Re: Chess Canada Webzine A SIMPLE TASK FAILED

I am talking about <http://members.chess.ca/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=86&Itemid=117>. It's not even consistent with <http://www.chess.ca/tlist.asp>