Chessbase: Forget about Elo

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Alan Baljeu
    • 2008-07-11
    • 425

    #1

    Chessbase: Forget about Elo

    Interesting article. According to the author, elite chess would do much better to have a Grand Slam type system of victory points for deciding who are the best players in the world.

  • Denton Cockburn
    • 2009-09-22
    • 251

    #2
    Re: Chessbase: Forget about Elo

    He didn't give much details for how this would be structured.

    How would new players be added? When would a player be dropped?
    Chess isn't like tennis, it's not like you're fit one year and then the next year you're washed up. What's the chess equivalent of a broken ankle? :)

    I actually like how the system is now. I do agree there should be more events, and probably fairer ways to determine who plays. I remember the horrid days of the FIDE World Championship, that was garbage (World Champion Ponomariov?)

    Comment

    • Nic Haynes
      • 2008-09-21
      • 69

      #3
      Re: Chessbase: Forget about Elo

      Originally posted by Denton Cockburn View Post
      He didn't give much details for how this would be structured.

      How would new players be added? When would a player be dropped?
      Chess isn't like tennis, it's not like you're fit one year and then the next year you're washed up. What's the chess equivalent of a broken ankle? :)

      I actually like how the system is now. I do agree there should be more events, and probably fairer ways to determine who plays. I remember the horrid days of the FIDE World Championship, that was garbage (World Champion Ponomariov?)
      Ponomariov is a better player then Kasimdzhanov, and much better then Khalifman, for whatever that is worth.

      Comment

      • Denton Cockburn
        • 2009-09-22
        • 251

        #4
        Re: Chessbase: Forget about Elo

        Originally posted by Nic Haynes View Post
        Ponomariov is a better player then Kasimdzhanov, and much better then Khalifman, for whatever that is worth.
        Which further reinforces my point :D

        I think Ponomariov sucks (in comparison to an Anand, Kramnik, Topalov, etc), and yet we can find other FIDE World Champions that he is better than...

        Comment

        • Stuart Brammall
          • 2008-10-06
          • 115

          #5
          Re: Chessbase: Forget about Elo

          Although I like the match system, a grand slam type system would not be nearly as bad as the FIDE world cup system.... Players like Khalifman and Kasimdzhanov may be good enough to win a knock-out on occasion, but it seems unlikely they could collect enough tournament points to be the world champion in a grand slam system comprised of multiple events.

          Comment

          Working...